Skip to main content

Equality is Biblical: Spiritual Formation Book 6

"To our reading of the Scriptures we bring our reason, experience, and the traditions of our faith, feeling down into the truth we trust is there waiting for us."

Equality is Biblical is the only book I've read where the questions have been as good as the main text. Usually study questions range from mediocre to dire, with a distinct feeling that they are only there because someone suggested it at the last minute. Penelope Wilcock, on the other hand, provides questions like surgical tools, probing deeply into what you believe and why. The book's main topic is the place of women in the church, but the questions cover everything from how we visualise God to the power of shame in society.

What are the main themes of this book?

The subtitle of Equality is Biblical is Lifting the Curse of Eve, and a large chunk of the book focuses on Genesis, analysing how the story has traditionally been interpreted, and offering alternative readings of the text. Then there is a look at women in church history, and a discussion of how Jesus and Paul regarded women.

Interwoven with all this are much broader ideas about what faith is - "a wild flower able to put down roots in the crevices of the highest crag"; how to read the Bible - "more like a map than a manual"; and how the surrounding culture influences our assumptions - "once change begins, so do questions... we start to see life differently".

The end result is a book which isn't really just about whether women are equal with men. Instead it uses that question to examine why we believe what we believe, how that changes, and where the Bible fits into all of it.

What did you like about the book?

Well, I'm the sort of person who, faced with a question like, "What imagery do you find helpful when you think about God?" will say, "That's really interesting, let me think about that". Not everyone wants to consider those kinds of things, but I found Wilcock's style of searching questions useful.

I particularly liked one where she encouraged you to write the words Scripture, Reason, Experience, Tradition on four pieces of card, and arrange them to reflect the importance they have for you. I decided that mine was Scripture built on by Reason (scientific knowledge, current moral norms) and Tradition built on by Experience (my own, and knowledge of others' experiences). In that arrangement, it wasn't that Scripture and Tradition were less important, but that they formed a base which was modified by new ideas or encounters.

What did you find difficult?

Some of the questions were definitely difficult! Do I think the original state of humanity was sinful or blessed? How do I discern good from evil? What difference does my faith make to standing for gender equality? I felt like I was barely scratching the surface in my response to some of these questions. There is a lot of depth to explore.

Did you learn something new?

For me, Equality is Biblical wasn't so much about being exposed to new ideas, but about looking at the ideas I already hold. Often these are acquired more or less subconsciously. So I think there's definitely value in asking, "What do I think about this? Where did I get that from? Who do I trust when they talk about this issue?"
Wilcock sees the Bible as having a direction of movement which continues into our lives today, so she encourages her readers not only to think about where they are now, but also how they have got there, and what might be around the next corner. As she says, "the search still unfolds, and the Way continues - there is always more to learn".

Will you do something differently?

 I read this book alongside Invisible Women by Caroline Criado Perez, which is about the gender data gap. She describes how, in so many fields, men are assumed to be the default and women are "non-standard" which leads to things being designed around men. Sometimes this is just annoying, like phones which don't fit in women's hands, or shelves which are too high. Sometimes it's dangerous: using crash test dummies which are based on the average man means that cars aren't designed to protect women properly.

Leaving women out of the picture is clearly not just a Christian trait. But perhaps, if we believe that God regards women as equally important, it gives us an added incentive to change things. I'm not sure what I will do, yet, but I want to give a quick plug to Lucy Rycroft, who noticed that children's Bible story books were always about men: Noah, Daniel, David. So she wrote Abigail and Deborah and Jael to help redress the balance. Once you see the gaps, it becomes easier to fill them in.

What is one thing you will remember?

Priscilla. Do you know Priscilla? I was introduced to her years ago, and was delighted. She was a leader in the early church, along with her husband Aquila, but most of what we know about her comes in those snippets at the end of Paul's letters, where he says, "Give my greetings to such-and-such, and tell this to so-and-so". There's a theory that she wrote the Letter to the Hebrews, which I would love to be true, because it's one of my favourite books. Penelope Wilcock mentions Priscilla as one of the women who was recognised and esteemed by Paul.

So, for all the women who have made the church what it is, and often flown under the radar to do so; and for all the women who are trying to make sure that women are seen and valued; for you, I remember Priscilla.


Lucy said…
Thanks for the very kind plug Martha! :)
Loved reading your review too. This is a book I've come across, but not read, so your thoughts on it were helpful (and the gender data gap book sounds very interesting too - I'd recently heard the same about crash test dummies - incredible!!!).

Popular posts from this blog

Supercars and Selfies on the South Coast

We drove south on a wet, wet Saturday in August. The windscreen wipers swished endlessly back and forth, as we debated whether it was worth stopping anywhere except for the overcrowded motorway services. By the time we reached Winchester, the wipers had subsided to an occasional flick across the screen. We decided to stop. Of course, as soon as we left the car park there was a brief shower, but we ducked into the City Mill, now a National Trust property. There was a large room full of the usual kind of displays about flour milling; a recently renovated garden; and downstairs, the mill race running at full tilt. The mill is built right across the River Itchen. Winchester City Mill garden The mill race Water wheel (awaiting renovation) We stayed dry as we explored further into Winchester. There was even some blue sky for our selfie by the cathedral! But as we walked back to the car the rain hit us like a hose on full blast. An overhanging building provided some slight shelter, but the wa

National Forest Way: Calke Abbey to Ashby de la Zouch

All the best walking blogs have maps on. I finally figured out how to add a route map to mine. If I get time, I'll add them to the previous posts as well, so you can see where I went. So, here are the two walks which made up the next stretch of the NFW. Walk 1  I started from the National Trust property and walked along by the lake, up the hill by the deer park, and down to Staunton Harold reservoir - all very familiar. Calke village postbox featured a highland cow on top. Lake at Calke Abbey Herd of deer   A short stretch on the road took me to Dimminsdale, which was new to me. There are records of mining at the site from the 13th century until the end of the 19th century. It's incredible to think that people worked there for so many hundreds of years. Now it is a secluded landscape of still pools and shaggy trees. Dimminsdale   I crossed a small section of the Staunton Harold estate, then went up a private lane with some rather nice houses. My turning point was where the Nati

Reading for Spiritual Formation 2023-24

I wasn't sure whether to read another set of theology books this year. Could the time I spend on it be better spent on something else? At what point does it become reading for the sake of it, without having much impact on my wider life? It's difficult to tell. However, as usual, I had a growing list of books I wanted to read. I do need to think about what I'm doing as well as what I'm reading, and I don't expect to continue this specific discipline indefinitely. But I decided there was space for at least one more year of Reading for Spiritual Formation. So, without further soul-searching: The Books. Three Mile an Hour God Kosuke Koyama Japanese theologians are few and far between; Christianity is still very much a niche religion in Japan. Kosuke Koyama was Japanese and appears to be both influential and accessible. Not every theologian is both! So I'm excited to read his recently republished book Three Mile an Hour God. It was originally written in 1979, and is